Real-world cases

Case study: the goods arrive and the buyer demands a discount because "the market has dropped"

A fruit shipment reaches the border just as prices crash, and the buyer asks for 30% off or they won't take delivery. Analysis and prevention through the contract.

Mr. Dan
Mr. Dan10+ years of export experience

This is a composite, illustrative case.

What happened

A company shipped fresh fruit on a verbal agreement, with the buyer paying only a very small deposit and the rest "on delivery". It was peak season, goods were backed up at the border and market prices fell sharply. The buyer said some fruit was substandard and asked for a 30% discount, or they wouldn't take the goods.

The seller's weak position

  • Fresh goods deteriorate with every day of waiting.
  • No clear contract on quality or inspection.
  • A deposit too small to cover the risk.
  • No replacement buyer on the spot.

Handling the situation

  • Ask the buyer for specific evidence about quality.
  • Look for a replacement buyer quickly through your network and associations.
  • Negotiate a reasonable discount and share the risk.

Prevention

  • A clear written contract: a fixed price, quality specifications, and final inspection at origin.
  • A large enough deposit, or payment before shipment.
  • Diversify buyers and markets so you're not dependent.
  • Avoid shipping perishables on a "ship first, agree the price later" basis.