Case study: the bank-change email and the payment that never arrived
The buyer paid, but the seller never received the money. A typical business email compromise story and the steps that should have been taken.
This is a composite, illustrative case based on common incidents in international trade.
What happened
A company shipped goods to a regular buyer in Europe and waited for the remaining 70% payment. The buyer said they'd paid and sent the transfer advice. But the money never arrived. On checking, the account number on the transfer advice belonged to an account in a third country.
The buyer explained that they'd received an email "from the company" saying the account had changed because the old bank was being audited. The email had the same signature, logo and writing style, but the domain differed by one character.
What went on
The fraudster had been monitoring the two sides' emails (possibly because an email password had leaked) and waited for the moment of payment to send the fake email.
How it was handled
- The buyer immediately asked the sending bank for a recall and reported it to the police.
- The company changed passwords, turned on two-factor authentication and checked email forwarding rules.
- The two sides negotiated responsibility.
Lessons
- The contract should state that bank details can only change with a signed and stamped letter confirmed by phone.
- Proactively remind buyers: "We never change our bank details by email."
- Secure your email with strong passwords and two-factor authentication.
- For any request to change bank details, call to verify using a number you already had.